Home > Uncategorized > More on Evil Rich People

More on Evil Rich People

If you have a dollar and you tear it up or put it in a mattress, you have done a public service. By removing money from the supply you have increased, however slightly, the value of all the others in circulation.

But who would tear up money! Lets say you put it in a bank. The bank is going to take your dollar and loan it to someone else. That someone else is, presumably, going to invest it in a home or in a business and hopefully reap more from the dollar than its face value. The bank gets interest and they pass a bit on to you for being such a nice guy and letting them use it.

Now we have these evil rich people… Horrible… They have a lot more than everybody else! Some say we should tax it away and spend it on those who have much much less. This works only in so far as you realize that now you have increased demand for, food lets say. Increased demand means increased prices, so the dollars you redistributed will now buy less of whatever the needier people needed.

Usually that would mean that supply would be increased. Those evil rich people typically don’t keep their money in mattresses (which would be fine) but they keep it in bank accounts and other investments which is what drives supply expansion.

You may see the issue, I hope so because there will be a test next Friday and it’s 50% of your grade.

That’s right. By redistributing we gave everyone more money (it could be government support like food stamps or something, rent subsidies, whatever), but it can now buy less and there is less capital available for the market to quickly react by expansion.

Practically no problem was solved. The amount of money you have makes no difference if it can’t buy you what you need. If we stick with food, you might notice that money has little or no nutritional value (although 90% of it does apparently contain cocaine, which makes me wonder what they are doing over the at bureau of engraving and printing…). If people were going hungry before, they are still going to be hungry, the hunger will just be spread more evenly.

If we back up a bit, the rich having amassed great wealth isn’t going to do anything for hunger either. There is no reason to have an expanded supply if there is no more demand.

Here’s an idea. Don’t worry about the rich! Lets have the government stop printing money! Yes a strange concept. Fiat currency is just another way to tax, but through inflation. Government needs money, government prints money, government spends money, money supply increases, money now worth less, government pays back borrowed dollars with dollars worth less than the original dollars…

Wait… WTF? Yes the wonders of modern economics.

Advertisements
Categories: Uncategorized
  1. 2011/03/31 at 13:44

    I’m not sure what you want me to respond to, here.

    * I don’t think rich people are evil.

    * I AM a rich person (as are nearly all of us in the US sitting at computers), by world and historic standards.

    * My friends are mostly all rich people.

    * Thus, again, I don’t think rich people are evil.

    * I DO agree with the repeated teachings found in the Bible teachings that…
    warn of the trappings of wealth,
    warn how easy it is to let wealth become an idol or a god to us,
    warn how easy it is to slip into oppressing the poor when you’re wealthier,
    stress how important it is to be content with what you have and not seek after wealth,
    stress how vitally important it is to people of faith that they seek to aid/be in community with the poor,
    emphasize the communal obligation to ease the suffering of the poor, foreign, marginalized and oppressed

    * I’m not in favor of redistributing wealth (ie, taking $10,000 from Rich Person A and giving it to Poor Person B).

    * As I have said in the past, though, I AM in favor of programs that save tax payer dollars. Seems to be a no-brainer to me.

    So, is there something in particular you’d think I ought to respond to?

  2. 2011/03/31 at 13:54

    Nope. I was just hoping I would find some opposition on at least one of my new posts!

  3. 2011/03/31 at 14:14

    Sorry, not so much so far.

  4. 2011/03/31 at 21:21

    Bummer.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: